Debra satz asymmetry thesis

Satz received the Walter J. Gores Award for Excellence in Teaching, Stanford’s highest teaching award, in 2004. The award cited her "extraordinary teaching that combines rigorous thought with serious engagement in the moral dilemmas facing humanity." She also co-founded and teaches in the Hope House Scholars Program, through which incarcerated women and volunteer faculty examine personal experience in the context of ethics, moral philosophy and social justice. Satz is now the Senior Associate Dean for the Humanities and the Arts.

Much of the evolution of social policy in the twentieth century has occurred around conflicts over the scope of markets. To what extent, under what conditions, and for what reasons should we limit the use of markets? Recently, American society has begun to experiment with markets in women's reproductive labor. Many people believe that markets in women's reproductive labor, as exemplified by contract pregnancy, are more problematic than other currently accepted labor markets. I will call this the asymmetry thesis because its proponents believe that there ought to be an asymmetry between our treatment of reproductive labor and our treatment of other forms of labor. Advocates of the asymmetry thesis hold that treating reproductive labor as a commodity, as something subject to the supply-and-demand principles that govern economic markets, is worse than treating other types of human labor as commodities. Is the asymmetry thesis true? And, if so, what are the reasons for thinking that it is true? My aims in this article are to criticize several popular ways of defending the asymmetry thesis and to offer an alternative defense....I focus my discussion on those arguments against contract pregnancy that depend on the asymmetry thesis. I believe that the asymmetry thesis both captures strong intuitions that exist in our society and provides a plausible argument against contract pregnancy.

If prost. Is wrong it is becauses of the effects of how men perceive women and how women perceive themselves, in our society prostitution represents women as the sexual servents of men

Learn more about how your support makes a difference or make a gift now

Learn more

debra satz asymmetry thesis

Debra satz asymmetry thesis

Learn more about how your support makes a difference or make a gift now

Action Action

debra satz asymmetry thesis

Debra satz asymmetry thesis

Action Action

debra satz asymmetry thesis

Debra satz asymmetry thesis

If prost. Is wrong it is becauses of the effects of how men perceive women and how women perceive themselves, in our society prostitution represents women as the sexual servents of men

Action Action

debra satz asymmetry thesis
Debra satz asymmetry thesis

Learn more about how your support makes a difference or make a gift now

Action Action

Debra satz asymmetry thesis

Action Action

debra satz asymmetry thesis

Debra satz asymmetry thesis

Much of the evolution of social policy in the twentieth century has occurred around conflicts over the scope of markets. To what extent, under what conditions, and for what reasons should we limit the use of markets? Recently, American society has begun to experiment with markets in women's reproductive labor. Many people believe that markets in women's reproductive labor, as exemplified by contract pregnancy, are more problematic than other currently accepted labor markets. I will call this the asymmetry thesis because its proponents believe that there ought to be an asymmetry between our treatment of reproductive labor and our treatment of other forms of labor. Advocates of the asymmetry thesis hold that treating reproductive labor as a commodity, as something subject to the supply-and-demand principles that govern economic markets, is worse than treating other types of human labor as commodities. Is the asymmetry thesis true? And, if so, what are the reasons for thinking that it is true? My aims in this article are to criticize several popular ways of defending the asymmetry thesis and to offer an alternative defense....I focus my discussion on those arguments against contract pregnancy that depend on the asymmetry thesis. I believe that the asymmetry thesis both captures strong intuitions that exist in our society and provides a plausible argument against contract pregnancy.

Action Action

debra satz asymmetry thesis

Debra satz asymmetry thesis

If prost. Is wrong it is becauses of the effects of how men perceive women and how women perceive themselves, in our society prostitution represents women as the sexual servents of men

Action Action

debra satz asymmetry thesis

Debra satz asymmetry thesis

Action Action

Bootstrap Thumbnail Second

Debra satz asymmetry thesis

Action Action

Bootstrap Thumbnail Third

Debra satz asymmetry thesis

Action Action